
As a longtime Superman fan, I was already looking forward to seeing the new movie, despite having reservations about the director, James Gunn. What I didn’t expect, however, was hearing about how seemingly pro-Palestine the movie is. The discourse wasn’t just on Twitter and Reddit, but also from movie critics that I follow, including those who often steer away from political discussions.
SPOILERS BELOW!
After watching the film, I can definitely see why people are making the connections to Gaza and calling it “obvious.” Early in the movie, it’s mentioned that the fictional Eastern European country of Boravia, a U.S. ally, invaded another fictional country, Jarhanpur. The contrast between the countries is easy to notice: Boravia has disproportionate military power, as evidenced by numerous tanks, Humvees, and an army of soldiers armed with assault rifles. Meanwhile, Jarhanpur is depicted as impoverished, the people in the crowd carrying rocks, sticks, and flags. Furthermore, the Jarhanpurians are portrayed by Middle Eastern, South Asian, and Black actors, compared to the Boravians, who are portrayed by white faces. It’s hard not to observe these differences and consider that Boravia and Jarhanpur represent Israel and Palestine, respectively.
The U.S. government and most of the general public is angry with Superman for intervening and stopping Boravia from invading Jarhanpur. In a scene where Lois interviews Clark/Superman about the events, she presses on him for “illegally entering a country” and not consulting with the U.S. secretary of defense or Boravian president Vasil Ghurkos. Superman becomes frustrated during the interview and asserts that he was not representing the U.S. or any nation, but rather acting on his accord because “people were going to die!” On a personal note, as I’ve expressed in an older blog post, I’ve been wanting to see a version of Superman where he is detached from patriotic allegiance to the U.S. and instead stands for what’s just, no matter who’s wrong. This is not only deconstructive of the “boy scout” version of the character we’re used to (or assume him to be), but it also, very simply, makes sense from a humanistic perspective.
I’ve read some pushback online where some argue that the allegory is meant to be Russia invading Ukraine, but I believe that argument falls apart if you pay attention to how the conflict is described, in addition to the casting. For one, Boravia is a U.S. ally, like Israel. Russia is not a U.S. ally. If this was indirectly about Russia, why would the U.S. government have a problem with Superman intervening to stop Boravia? The support for Ukraine against Russia in the U.S. has been nationwide, with politicians, corporations, and workplaces going as far as posting images of Ukrainian flags, for example. While Ghurkos speaks with a stereotypical Russian accent (and in a “mock Russian” language), he appears to be more of a stand-in for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Needless to say, it’s not a flattering depiction at all. Another reason why the Russia and Ukraine argument doesn’t work is because, as mentioned earlier, the Jarhanpurians ethnically look more like Palestinians than Ukrainians.
At one point in their argument, Lois mentions that Jarhanpur is not “innocent” and that Superman’s actions could cause “replacing one tyrannical regime with another.” This sentiment echoes Zionist propaganda that vilifies Palestinians through Orientalist and Islamophobic tropes: “They hate women,” “they execute LGBTQ people,” “they voted for Hamas,” “they’re anti-semites” — all of which is meant to justify genocide and ethnic cleansing. I was pleasantly surprised when Superman responded by saying that the Jarhanpurians don’t need to be innocent or perfect (I forgot the exact words he used) in order for him to protect them from slaughter. This reminded me of what Palestinians have been saying for decades about the “perfect victim” being an “impossible standard” imposed upon Palestinians from the west.
The allegory doesn’t stop there. It’s later revealed that the tyrannical billionaire Lex Luthor, who is obviously based on Donald Trump, has been supplying weapons to Boravia in exchange for a significant portion of Jarhanpurian land. In relation to Israel, the U.S. is not just complicit, but an active partner in funding, arming, and enabling Israeli settler colonialism and genocide. Back in February, we’ve heard Trump propose that the U.S. will “take over” and “own” the Gaza Strip after further displacing Palestinians.
It’s refreshing that the narrative didn’t resort to a “both sides are wrong” message. It’s also nice to see Superman on the right side of history and truly fighting for justice. As Charlie Von Peterffy writes:
“Superman fights for justice for all. Not for the powerful, not for his country, and not for anyone or anything in particular. He fights for anyone and everyone who needs help. As frightened children raise a makeshift flag of Superman’s logo, chanting ‘Superman! Superman! Superman!’ with tanks staring them down, one can’t not think of similar imagery of Palestinian disabled, children, and elders getting fenced in and shot at by the now American-Israeli backed food distribution centers’ security around Gaza.”
I don’t know what Gunn’s intentions were and I’m not a fan of giving people credit they don’t deserve, but I think Patrick Marlborough’s comments about Andor‘s Gaza allegory are relevant here: “Author and studio intent have nothing to do with it” because the movie “arrives within this reality.” Even if Gunn didn’t intend to draw the parallels, moviegoers and critics are being outspoken about the connections, and filmmakers, studios, and deniers are going to have to engage with it.
As for the rest of the movie, it was too silly for my taste. I didn’t like Zack Snyder’s Man of Steel (2013) because of its grim (and arguably Ayn Randian) characterization of Superman and the Kents, but tonally, this new movie goes too far in the opposite direction. I like that it unapologetically embraces the comic book and fantastical elements of the DC universe, but there weren’t enough serious and emotional moments for me. The movie doesn’t take time to breathe. There are missed opportunities to allow characters to sit in their emotions without being abruptly disrupted by humor. I understand the need for humor after Snyder’s DC films were severely lacking in that department, but I don’t think Gunn found a good balance of humor and drama.
I also didn’t care for the depiction of Lex Luthor. As important as it to address the injustices caused by the Trump administration, the character of Lex is so cartoony that the impact of the political message is diminished. David Corenswet and Rachel Brosnahan were great in their roles, but I wish there was more focus on developing their characters. The film relies on the audience’s pre-existing familiarity with these characters instead of a fresh reboot. With regard to the new characters, I loved Mr. Terrific and hope we see more of him in the future.
My personal favorite Superman story is in the recent Superman & Lois TV show (which is severely underrated). As much as I love Christopher Reeve, Tyler Hoechlin has become my favorite portrayal of Clark/Superman. I was fully satisfied with that show, so I’m not as disappointed with Gunn’s Superman. I do appreciate the ambition to address important issues, such as the genocide in Gaza, while also embracing the fantastical and comic book origins in this newly established DC cinematic universe. I just hope we get more focus on the characters and a balance between the humor and serious tones.









