From Jarhanpur to Gaza: The Israel-Palestine Allegory in Superman (2025)

As a longtime Superman fan, I was already looking forward to seeing the new movie, despite having reservations about the director, James Gunn. What I didn’t expect, however, was hearing about how seemingly pro-Palestine the movie is. The discourse wasn’t just on Twitter and Reddit, but also from movie critics that I follow, including those who often steer away from political discussions.

SPOILERS BELOW!

After watching the film, I can definitely see why people are making the connections to Gaza and calling it “obvious.” Early in the movie, it’s mentioned that the fictional Eastern European country of Boravia, a U.S. ally, invaded another fictional country, Jarhanpur. The contrast between the countries is easy to notice: Boravia has disproportionate military power, as evidenced by numerous tanks, Humvees, and an army of soldiers armed with assault rifles. Meanwhile, Jarhanpur is depicted as impoverished, the people in the crowd carrying rocks, sticks, and flags. Furthermore, the Jarhanpurians are portrayed by Middle Eastern, South Asian, and Black actors, compared to the Boravians, who are portrayed by white faces. It’s hard not to observe these differences and consider that Boravia and Jarhanpur represent Israel and Palestine, respectively.

The U.S. government and most of the general public is angry with Superman for intervening and stopping Boravia from invading Jarhanpur. In a scene where Lois interviews Clark/Superman about the events, she presses on him for “illegally entering a country” and not consulting with the U.S. secretary of defense or Boravian president Vasil Ghurkos. Superman becomes frustrated during the interview and asserts that he was not representing the U.S. or any nation, but rather acting on his accord because “people were going to die!” On a personal note, as I’ve expressed in an older blog post, I’ve been wanting to see a version of Superman where he is detached from patriotic allegiance to the U.S. and instead stands for what’s just, no matter who’s wrong. This is not only deconstructive of the “boy scout” version of the character we’re used to (or assume him to be), but it also, very simply, makes sense from a humanistic perspective.

I’ve read some pushback online where some argue that the allegory is meant to be Russia invading Ukraine, but I believe that argument falls apart if you pay attention to how the conflict is described, in addition to the casting. For one, Boravia is a U.S. ally, like Israel. Russia is not a U.S. ally. If this was indirectly about Russia, why would the U.S. government have a problem with Superman intervening to stop Boravia? The support for Ukraine against Russia in the U.S. has been nationwide, with politicians, corporations, and workplaces going as far as posting images of Ukrainian flags, for example. While Ghurkos speaks with a stereotypical Russian accent (and in a “mock Russian” language), he appears to be more of a stand-in for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Needless to say, it’s not a flattering depiction at all. Another reason why the Russia and Ukraine argument doesn’t work is because, as mentioned earlier, the Jarhanpurians ethnically look more like Palestinians than Ukrainians.

At one point in their argument, Lois mentions that Jarhanpur is not “innocent” and that Superman’s actions could cause “replacing one tyrannical regime with another.” This sentiment echoes Zionist propaganda that vilifies Palestinians through Orientalist and Islamophobic tropes: “They hate women,” “they execute LGBTQ people,” “they voted for Hamas,” “they’re anti-semites” — all of which is meant to justify genocide and ethnic cleansing. I was pleasantly surprised when Superman responded by saying that the Jarhanpurians don’t need to be innocent or perfect (I forgot the exact words he used) in order for him to protect them from slaughter. This reminded me of what Palestinians have been saying for decades about the “perfect victim” being an “impossible standard” imposed upon Palestinians from the west.

The allegory doesn’t stop there. It’s later revealed that the tyrannical billionaire Lex Luthor, who is obviously based on Donald Trump, has been supplying weapons to Boravia in exchange for a significant portion of Jarhanpurian land. In relation to Israel, the U.S. is not just complicit, but an active partner in funding, arming, and enabling Israeli settler colonialism and genocide. Back in February, we’ve heard Trump propose that the U.S. will “take over” and “own” the Gaza Strip after further displacing Palestinians.

It’s refreshing that the narrative didn’t resort to a “both sides are wrong” message. It’s also nice to see Superman on the right side of history and truly fighting for justice. As Charlie Von Peterffy writes:

“Superman fights for justice for all. Not for the powerful, not for his country, and not for anyone or anything in particular. He fights for anyone and everyone who needs help. As frightened children raise a makeshift flag of Superman’s logo, chanting ‘Superman! Superman! Superman!’ with tanks staring them down, one can’t not think of similar imagery of Palestinian disabled, children, and elders getting fenced in and shot at by the now American-Israeli backed food distribution centers’ security around Gaza.”

I don’t know what Gunn’s intentions were and I’m not a fan of giving people credit they don’t deserve, but I think Patrick Marlborough’s comments about Andor‘s Gaza allegory are relevant here: “Author and studio intent have nothing to do with it” because the movie “arrives within this reality.” Even if Gunn didn’t intend to draw the parallels, moviegoers and critics are being outspoken about the connections, and filmmakers, studios, and deniers are going to have to engage with it.

As for the rest of the movie, it was too silly for my taste. I didn’t like Zack Snyder’s Man of Steel (2013) because of its grim (and arguably Ayn Randian) characterization of Superman and the Kents, but tonally, this new movie goes too far in the opposite direction. I like that it unapologetically embraces the comic book and fantastical elements of the DC universe, but there weren’t enough serious and emotional moments for me. The movie doesn’t take time to breathe. There are missed opportunities to allow characters to sit in their emotions without being abruptly disrupted by humor. I understand the need for humor after Snyder’s DC films were severely lacking in that department, but I don’t think Gunn found a good balance of humor and drama.

I also didn’t care for the depiction of Lex Luthor. As important as it to address the injustices caused by the Trump administration, the character of Lex is so cartoony that the impact of the political message is diminished. David Corenswet and Rachel Brosnahan were great in their roles, but I wish there was more focus on developing their characters. The film relies on the audience’s pre-existing familiarity with these characters instead of a fresh reboot. With regard to the new characters, I loved Mr. Terrific and hope we see more of him in the future.

My personal favorite Superman story is in the recent Superman & Lois TV show (which is severely underrated). As much as I love Christopher Reeve, Tyler Hoechlin has become my favorite portrayal of Clark/Superman. I was fully satisfied with that show, so I’m not as disappointed with Gunn’s Superman. I do appreciate the ambition to address important issues, such as the genocide in Gaza, while also embracing the fantastical and comic book origins in this newly established DC cinematic universe. I just hope we get more focus on the characters and a balance between the humor and serious tones.

The Refusal to See Gaza in Andor

It’s been a while since I’ve posted here, but I wanted to share some of my thoughts about Andor season 2 (which I had posted elsewhere when the show was airing). SPOILERS below.

When I saw episodes 7-9, I thought they were absolutely riveting. I’ve had mixed feelings lately about Star Wars and other fandom franchises in terms of how effective anti-war themes are in sci-fi/fantasy during a time of genocide. But even the cynical part of me was moved by Mon Mothma’s speech in episode 9, which felt plucked out of real world events where Palestinians and people of conscious courageously and defiantly condemn Israel’s genocide in the face of aggressive opposition and denial.

What does it say about our world where I can turn on the TV to watch Andor, a sci-fi series with timely revolutionary themes that are clearly commenting on fascism, imperialism, and military occupation, but can also change to channel to see a live-streamed genocide taking place in Palestine, where real people are suffering unfathomable horrors and devastation? One is entertainment, the other is reality.

I’d like to think that Mon Mothma is calling our attention away from a galaxy far, far away, and to look at our world, to the imperialist and colonial violence that is happening right now simultaneously as we watch a fictional story for entertainment. I don’t believe media alone is going to save us, and the show, like anything, is not without critique. But the significance it carries is reflective of the shift in public opinion about Israel and Palestine.

When asked if intended to draw parallels to Gaza, showrunner Tony Gilroy dodged the question. However, as Patrick Marlborough asserts in his article Andor in the Genocide, “author and studio intent have nothing to do with it: the show arrives within this reality, fully armed to aggressively tackle it.” Furthermore, a trend I’ve noticed on Reddit, Twitter, and other social media discussions is that some people will say, “No, it’s not about Palestine, it’s about World War II,” or “It’s about Russia and Ukraine.” While it’s undeniable that the Ghorman Front are inspired by the French Resistance during World War II (the casting of French actors, the fictional yet French-sounding language), the Ghorman massacre can also been seen as analogous to the Palestinian Great March of Return that began in 2018, where Israeli snipers opened fire on unarmed Palestinians, “killing 266 people and injuring almost 30,000 others in one year.”

Additionally, the speech by Mon Mothma solidifies the allegory to Gaza, not just because of the first line that mentions “genocide,” but the second line where she says, “Yes! Genocide!” The latter is in response to other Imperial senators expressing offense and outrage at her use of the word “genocide.” This is exactly what we are seeing happening now when Palestinians and their allies are vilified, censored, suspended, and/or fired when they charge Israel with genocide.

It’s not that one cannot draw parallels to other atrocities, past or present. It’s just very telling that people want to avoid mentioning Gaza/Palestine. It’s that refusal to acknowledge genocide against Palestinians that make it the most similar to the Ghorman massacre. Marlborough asserts that to “say Andor is little more than an allegory for fascist-colonial-genocidial projects of the past — not Israel, specifically — is to tacitly admit that’s exactly what Israel is, given the force of the parallels.”

Seeing the massive shift in public opinion, even through allegory, makes me hopeful about the future. I still have complicated feelings around all of this, but regardless of what the writers intended, the connections are being made by viewers and Star Wars fans. I agree with the person who posted the tweet above: Don’t let this opposition and outrage against genocide “linger in the realm of fiction.” Denise Gough, who plays Dedra Meero, is one of several Andor actors who has been doing just that. In her interview with Breakthrough News, she states:

“I don’t really have a choice, it feels to me. I don’t have a choice, I have to say something. And also what I will say too is, we’re being asked by Palestinian people to speak and so, in years to come when people say, ‘I didn’t know what to do.’ It’s like, but we know what we’re being asked to do… [I]t’s not easy, I will also say that, I’m nervous… It’s nerve-wracking, but it’s not half – it’s not even a touch of what is is going on for them.”

As great as it is to see Star Wars fans recognizing the parallels to the real world, I think it’s more impactful when cast and crew members behind-the-scenes of Andor speak out and name the injustice. One can hope more people will speak out. As Andor reminds us, “Rebellions are built on hope.”

Barbie’s White Feminism Problem

WARNING: SPOILERS BELOW! If you haven’t seen Barbie yet and don’t want to be spoiled, please read after you’ve seen the film.

I liked Barbie overall, but it’s hard to praise the film without critique (more on this later). It could have been a generic apolitical movie about a doll coming to life and entering the real world, but it subverted that conventional route and addressed important themes like feminism, patriarchy, and toxic masculinity. Although there was plenty of humor, there were also very powerful and emotional moments as well. The movie provokes timely conversations, and there was plenty of that with the group of people that I saw the movie with.

One of the major themes in the movie highlights how difficult it is being a woman. As a cisgender Pakistani Muslim man, I know I’ll never be able to understand what those experiences are like. I appreciated the movie for engaging with these topics and creating opportunities for people to discuss and reflect on its overall message about how damaging patriarchy is. The scenes that talk about the double standards and challenges that women experience created conversations about sexism and misogyny, including painful ones about internalized misogyny. It reminded me of times at a previous workplace when a couple of women co-workers would ask me if I was concerned about having a daughter because “girls are harder to raise” than boys. This was followed by questions about what rules I would establish if my daughter wanted to date, yet this question was not asked of any of the people in the room who had sons.

As much as I liked the movie, what was most frustrating about it was that it doesn’t really acknowledge race or intersectionality. There seemingly was a conscious effort to make the cast racially diverse. Women of color Barbies are visually prominent in the film, but the narrative doesn’t go beyond this visual diversity. There is hardly any mentioning of race or racism, let alone a deeper acknowledgment about how intersecting factors of identity create diverse experiences for BIPOC, LGBTQIA2S+ women and femmes, etc. At one point, it seemed like the film shifted focus away from Barbie and centered on the Latina characters Gloria and Sasha played by America Ferrera and Ariana Greenblatt, respectively. The shift kind of reminded me of Hitchcock’s Psycho, which changes the protagonist midway through the movie, but Barbie’s character gets re-centered, expectedly, shortly after some great scenes with Gloria and Sasha.

Gloria’s speech is by far the most memorable dialogue in the film, but it neglected the opportunity to address race and explore questions like, what was it like for Latina girls and other girls of color to grow up playing with Barbie toys that traditionally targeted white girls? My wife, also Pakistani and Muslim, wrote this critique about the scene:

All I wanted was Gloria’s race to have been acknowledged in a meaningful way and it would have been as easy as having a line in her monologue about having to live up to white beauty standards as a WoC. She imprinted her feelings onto her Barbie, which had repercussions, because she no longer saw the current version of her reflected in her doll.

Part of growing up would have also been realizing that Barbie is a different race than she is (has traditionally been marketed to white girls), and that could have contributed to the fractured sense of self that led to the trip in between the worlds.

There are many critiques that the film depicts white feminism, and this is true, unfortunately. Sasha makes one comment about Barbie being a “white savior,” but it’s very “LOL” and played for laughs. There is no follow up or analysis of it. There’s another moment where Gloria mentions European colonizers bringing smallpox to Indigenous People, but it’s (1) another joke, and (2) a false equivalency to the what she’s comparing it to. I’ve seen Indigenous People online criticizing that “joke.”

Another major critique is that the film is very binary and heteronormative. I know some people are reading the Allan character as gay or queer, but again, this isn’t named in the movie. I’m all for people reading Allan’s character in however they wish, though. I just don’t think the filmmakers can take credit for that.

As I said earlier, the film’s white feminist politics make it difficult to praise completely, and it’s even more nauseating when some fans of the movie argue, “[I]t’s not fair or realistic to expect a doll with such a complex and muddy history to carry the weight of relating to every woman’s story.” I agree that the movie cannot address “everything,” but I think this speaks to a larger, structural problem where BIPOC women are routinely told that their voices/critiques are not valid, that they expect “too much,” and should just settle for white feminism. I also think it’s kind of sad that the late bell hooks gave us a clear and radical definition of feminism in 1984 (or maybe earlier than that) that challenged the conventional white definition of feminism (i.e. “feminism is the notion that women are the social equals of men”) and yet the latter is still the popularized definition in mainstream media and discourse. I’ll end my post with an excerpt from her book, Feminist Theory: From Margin to Center (and I think this quote highlights the problems in Barbie’s political framework):

Most people in the United States think of feminism as a movement that aims to make women the social equals of men. This broad definition, popularized by the media and mainstream segments of the movement, raises problematic questions. Since men are not equals in white supremacist, capitalist, patriarchal class structure, which men do women want to be equal to? Do women share a common vision of what equality means? Implicit in this simplistic definition of women’s liberation is a dismissal of race and class as factors that, in conjunction with sexism, determine the extent to which an individual will be discriminated against, exploited, or oppressed. Bourgeois white women interested in women’s rights issues have been satisfied with simple definitions for obvious reasons. Rhetorically placing themselves in the same social category as oppressed women, they are not anxious to call attention to race and class privilege.

Feminism is the struggle to end sexist oppression. Feminist struggle takes place anytime anywhere any female or male resists sexism, sexist exploitation, and oppression. Feminist movement happens when groups of people come together with an organized strategy to take action to eliminate patriarchy.

Obi-Wan Kenobi Continues a Disturbing Trope for Women of Color Characters

Promotional poster of Tala Durith, played by Indira Varma.

The following post contains spoilers for Obi-Wan Kenobi, The Clone Wars animated series, the prequel films, and Battlestar Galactica. At the time of this writing, episodes 1-5 of Obi-Wan Kenobi have aired on Disney+.

Edgar Allan Poe once wrote, “The death, then, of a beautiful woman is, unquestionably, the most poetical topic in the world.”

This quote was brought to my attention several years ago when I read a post written by prozacpark. She mentioned Poe’s words when discussing the abrupt death of a woman of color character, Dualla/Dee, in the TV series Battlestar Galactica. Prozacpark expressed how Dee’s death fit into the larger trend of killing women characters in fiction:

Because death – always beautiful for women – redeems them, restores them to their beauty, happiness, and honor or what the fuck ever.

Because in death, they become a blank text that can be written upon – having nothing but the body that patriarchy finds so interesting, that the male gaze finds easy to objectify – just as Dee became a text to be written on… so the writers could impart some message using her.

She continues by arguing that killing off women characters reduces them to symbols of “some man’s revolution,” as well as “of everything humanity has lost, and everything it continues to lose.”

As a longtime Star Wars fan, I’ve noticed this misogynistic trope as well within the films and TV shows. One of the most obvious examples is the death of Padmé Amidala, who, according to the medical droid, simply “lost the will to live.” Padmé’s death serves to provide Anakin/Vader with emotional distress and trauma, or, as feminist fandom calls it, “manpain.” There is a theory that argues Sheev Palpatine killed her (which I personally believe), but the pattern of killing off women characters in Star Wars is the larger focus here. Duchess Satine Kryze is another woman character in Star Wars who was victimized by this trope. One could argue that Satine “needed to die” because she does not appear in the later films, but the purpose of her death was for Obi-Wan’s “emotional development.”

Women of color characters in particular have been terribly treated by Star Wars writers. In The Clone Wars animated series, there is a 4-episode arc about the rebels on Onderon (season 5, episodes 2-5). In addition to featuring strong political parallels with occupied Palestine, the episodes introduce us to well-developed Black characters, specifically Saw Gerrera and his sister Steela Gerrera. With Steela, voiced by Dawn-Lyen Gardner, we see a Black woman resistance leader fighting against the brutal droid occupation of her planet. When she and Lux Bonteri, a young white male politician-turned-rebel fighter, nearly fell off a cliff in the final battle, Ahsoka Tano attempted to save them by using the Force. Ahsoka managed to float Lux to safety, but her efforts to save Steela failed.

Steela’s death was not necessary. In fact, it served no other purpose except to transform her into a symbol and have her remembered as a martyr of the revolution. Meanwhile, the young white man, Lux, survives and is re-appointed as senator of Onderon and rejoins the planet with the Republic. His survival was important for larger political purposes, whereas Steela’s purpose was to die for Onderon’s independence so that white men could lead. Referring to Steela, Lux eulogized, “Her sacrifice gave Onderon its freedom.” Steela’s death fuels the notion that Black women must die or sacrifice themselves to inspire revolutions led mostly by white people. Later, in Star Wars Rebels, we learn of the emotional impact Steela’s death had on her brother, Saw. While we see Saw in Rogue One, there is no mention of Steela, but one can interpret that he was alluding to her when he delivered the heartbreaking line, “There’s not much of me left.” Unfortunately, this is again another example of how a woman’s death provides manpain for a male character.

In the 2018 film Solo, Thandie Newton became the first Black woman to play a human/non-alien leading role in a live-action Star Wars film. However, like Steela, her character Val was killed. Newton has been outspoken about how her character’s death was a “big, big mistake.” In an interview with Inverse, Newton was straightforward about her disappointment, stating: “You don’t kill off the first Black woman to ever have a real role in a Star Wars movie. Like, are you fucking joking?”

What’s worse is that Val did not die in the original script. In other words, Newton signed onto Solo with the understanding that her character would survive. She shared that Val’s death was decided during filming. “And it was much more just to do with the time we had to do the scenes,” she stated. “It’s much easier just to have me die than it is to have me fall into a vacuum of space so I can come back sometime.”

As Monique Jones pointed out in her article on Shadow and Act, Val’s death was a sacrifice so “Beckett, Han and Chewbacca could escape from a botched heist with their lives.” In other words, her death was “only done in service to the plot and to give the male characters something to act against.” Furthermore, Jones writes that Val’s death reinforced the notion that Black women are disposable, especially in the sci-fi and fantasy genres.

While my excitement for Obi-Wan Kenobi was already higher than any Star Wars film or TV show since The Phantom Menace, I was also happy that Indira Varma was cast to play a substantial role. South Asian women in particular have had limited presence in the Star Wars universe. As great as it was to see Janina Gavankar’s likeness and voice used for the main character, Iden Versio, in the Star Wars Battlefront II video game, I thought she was deserving of a live-action presence in the films and shows as well. Similarly, Tiya Sircar voiced the fan-favorite character Sabine Wren on Star Wars Rebels, but was not cast to play the live-action version of the character in the upcoming Ahsoka series. Natasha Liu Bordizzo was cast to play Sabine instead. While it’s great that another woman of color will be playing Sabine, it’s unfortunate that Sircar was not brought back to play the same character she had been playing before. We saw Lucasfilm provide this opportunity (and rightfully so) to Katee Sackhoff, who had voiced Bo-Katan in The Clone Wars and now plays the live-action version of the same character. My issue with Lucasfilm’s casting decision is not Bordizzo’s fault by any means. I’m sure she will do great in the role.

Prior to Varma, the only live-action role we saw for South Asian women was Queen Jamillia in Attack of the Clones. Played by Indian actress Ayesha Dharker, she appeared in a very short scene and was never seen again in the prequel trilogy. In Obi-Wan Kenobi, we learn that Varma’s character Tala Durith is a former Imperial officer who leaves the Empire after realizing the atrocities she has been complicit in. She joins a resistance movement called The Path that helps surviving Jedi and Force-sensitive people escape the Empire. While we have seen many characters defect from the Empire in the Star Wars universe, I don’t think characters like Finn and Bodhi Rook were given enough development and screen time to show us the tremendous impact their decisions had on their lives. I was hoping this would not be the case with Tala, but unfortunately, just as we were getting to learn more about her, she sacrifices herself in Episode 5 of the series.

Just as Newton asserted that she was the first Black woman with a leading live-action role in Star Wars, a similar point could be raised by Varma. That is, she was the first South Asian woman to play a prominent live-action role in Star Wars, only to be killed off. Some of the reactions to Tala’s death that I’ve been reading and hearing from fans has been concerning. One movie critic, a white woman, described Tala’s “sacrifice for the greater good” as being “wonderful.” I’ve seen comments on Twitter from fans who called her death “heroic.” This romanticization of Tala’s death aligns with Edgar Allan Poe’s comment about “the death [of] a beautiful woman” being “unquestionably, the most poetical topic in the world.”

Like Steela and Val, Tala did not need to die. In fact, she refused to be saved by Obi-Wan. Her death serves to deepen Obi-Wan’s manpain – his overall guilt that he is responsible for all the deaths in the galaxy that were caused by his former apprentice. Tala dies in order to protect the two white lead characters, Obi-Wan and Leia, because their stories are more important than hers. Before anyone argues that she sacrificed herself because she felt guilty about following orders to hunt Jedi and Force-sensitive survivors of Order 66, do we need to be reminded of the redemption arcs that were given to white male characters like Anakin Skywalker and Ben Solo?

It’s worth mentioning Rose Tico, played wonderfully by Kelly Marie Tran. Although Rose was not killed off, her character was significantly reduced to a supporting character with limited screen time in The Rise of Skywalker. It is well-known at this point that Kelly Marie Tran received horribly racist and misogynistic comments online – more specifically, anti-Asian misogyny – after the release of The Last Jedi. Instead of giving her a substantial role in the sequel, J.J. Abrams and his co-screenwriter Chris Terrio essentially made her character inconsequential. Terrio has gone on record to state that they did not deliberately sideline Rose, but deliberately or not, the characters who became prioritized were the two white leads, Rey and Kylo/Ben (a point that John Boyega also raised).

Like John Boyega and Tran, Moses Ingram has also been on the receiving end of racist and misogynistic abuse. The racism against Ingram speaks to the larger problem of anti-Blackness and misogynoir, including in fandom spaces. Episode 5 of Obi-Wan Kenobi revealed much more complexity with Reva’s character, but I believe the show would have benefitted from having more than 6 episodes. I personally would have liked to have seen more development and screen time with Reva’s character. I love the concept of her hunting Darth Vader and deceiving him, but the execution felt rushed. Again, there’s only so much that can be done with character development when there’s only 6 episodes. We don’t know what Reva’s fate will be in the season finale, but I’m really hoping that her character doesn’t die. It’s obvious that we don’t see her character in the original trilogy and sequel trilogy, but to me, that’s not enough to say that her character should be killed.

In closing, martyring women of color characters in service of white characters is a disturbing trope that needs to be challenged, not just in the minds of writers and filmmakers, but also in the minds of fans who romanticize their deaths. This, of course, is not just a problem with Star Wars, but in other franchises as well (e.g. Dualla from Battlestar Galactica and Rue from The Hunger Games).

Perpetuating this trope denies women of color, and communities of color in general, stories of their survival through struggles with colonialism, genocide, imperialism, sexist oppression, and other forms of oppression.

As prozacpark writes: “You know what’s better than that proverbial beautiful death? SURVIVING.”

The Batman Review: A Refreshing and Subversive Take on the Batman Mythos

Minor spoilers ahead:

One of the concerns I had going into The Batman was that it would be too similar to Nolan’s “grounded in reality” approach to the Batman universe. Stylistically, yes, it takes Nolan’s realism even further, but thematically, the film is the complete opposite of the Nolan trilogy, which is the best thing about it. In short, it subverts many of Nolan’s political themes.

I appreciated the film’s attempt to address white male privilege and systemic injustice, particularly classism and corruption among politicians and the police. I also liked the de-romanticization of Bruce’s father, Thomas Wayne. However, the movie raises these issues and critiques cautiously. It refuses to cross a line and instead relies on a safer narrative by the end. It’s a reminder that mainstream superhero movies can only go so far with social justice messages. At the very least, it’s refreshing to see a Batman story that acknowledges some of the foundational problems with the character (unlike the Nolan and Snyder films, which leaned in strongly towards a Frank Miller-esque, fascist Batman).

I liked what they did with The Riddler, though the “understandable villain with legitimate goals, but extreme methods” has become a trope, hasn’t it? Erik Kilmonger, Ocean Master, and Magneto come to mind (though I know they’re not exactly the same). What’s frustrating about this trope is that the villains often raise legitimate concerns that typically align more with leftist politics, but the overall narrative wants to make sure we don’t fully root for these villains, thus resorting to having these villains commit atrocious and over-the-top acts of violence. If only the protagonists had these radical views…

Those issues aside, a major highlight for me is Robert Pattinson’s performance as the character, even though I disagree with the approach that Bruce Wayne is the “mask” that Batman wears (I prefer Michael Keaton’s interpretation that Batman is the “shadow” of Bruce Wayne). Pattinson brings an emotional depth to the character that’s more pronounced than previous versions. His Batman voice thankfully isn’t like the growling and over-exaggerated Christian Bale version, but more quietly intense like Keaton. Based on the reviews I’ve read, I was expecting a hyper-masculine Batman, but it was nice to see that this wasn’t the case (at least from my perspective). The fight scenes were a bit brutal, but nothing compared to Snyder’s Batman, which was a character obsessed with “manliness.” While Pattinson’s Batman had a more militarized look and resorted to some brutal tactics, I found there was a vulnerability he brought to the role as well. Furthermore, there was growth for his character by the end. I was surprised that I actually liked Batman calling himself a symbol of hope and engaging with the citizens of Gotham. I do prefer the Tim Burton Batman where you get the sense that people would rather stay away from him, but I also liked this alternate Matt Reeves version, where a more interpersonal connection between Batman and the people is possible. Pattinson’s Batman is not beyond critique, of course, but better than the Nolan and Snyder versions at least.

I thought Zoe Kravitz’s portrayal of Selina Kyle was great (annoyingly they don’t call her Catwoman, just like Nolan’s version, because realism, I guess). I’m glad that some of the leftist critiques were voiced by her, not just by The Riddler. I disagree with the criticism I’ve read that her scenes distracted from the overall narrative; I thought everything flowed nicely. I don’t think she had as much screen time as Michelle Pfeiffer in Batman Returns, but I think some depth was provided for her character (not so much for the romance element between her and Batman). Hopefully we’ll see more of her in the sequels.

I wasn’t too impressed with Michael Giacchino’s score initially, but it grew on me (“Escaped Crusader” is probably my favorite on the soundtrack, as it has nice touches of Danny Elfman and Shirley Walker). The Nirvana influence was effective, not just in the film’s use of “Something in the Way,” but in Bruce Wayne’s look (Matt Reeves stated that his depiction of Bruce was inspired by Kurt Cobain).

Overall, I liked seeing Batman through a noir, detective-driven lens. It definitely draws a lot of influence from David Fincher’s Se7en (which I thought was perfect because I remember thinking for YEARS that I’d love to see a Batman movie like Se7en). It’s a shame that the DC cinematic universe can’t restart with this movie. The realistic approach doesn’t allow for supernatural and fantastical elements (a flying character like Superman can’t exist in this world, for example).

I’ve posted about this elsewhere on social media before, but both Nolan and Reeves arrogantly view Batman as being exceptional among the other superhero characters. They don’t embrace him as a comic book character and are more interested in grounded him in the real world. This interpretation is not without its strengths, but I think it takes away too much from the character and source material. Again, it’s a shame because I think Reeves could do an amazing job with something more fantastical and connected to the larger DC universe.

The Psychological Depth of Batman Returns

I’ve been revisiting the Tim Burton Batman films because of the recent buzz around Batman (whether it’s for The Batman or Michael Keaton returning to the role in The Flash and Batgirl). My appreciation for Batman Returns grows every time I watch it, and it’s unfortunate that many of its deeper, psychological themes are overlooked by mainstream audiences. I was discussing (arguing, really) with someone who proclaimed that The Dark Knight is not only the best Batman movie, but one of the greatest films of all time. While I agree that The Dark Knight is quite thrilling and entertaining with great performances (minus Christian Bale as Bruce/Batman), I think the film is very overrated.

The Dark Knight may excel in suspense, but it lacks depth and complexity, particularly with regard to character development. For example, as amazing as Heath Ledger’s performance is, the characterization of The Joker is very simplistic. People tend to argue that Nolan’s/Ledger’s Joker is born out of trauma, as exemplified in how his story about his scars changes, but he ultimately serves as an allegory for the “War on Terror” and it’s apparent in the film that Nolan is less interested in a character study than he is in terrifying us with a Joker who just wants to “watch the world burn.” This, to me, is more like a fairy tale villain, a character who has no motive and just kills for the sake of it. Given Nolan’s “realistic” and “grounded” approach to the Batman universe, a villain who just wants to watch the world burn for no apparent reason is quite unrealistic.

There are many reasons why Michael Keaton will always be my definitive Bruce Wayne/Batman. Similarly, there are many reasons why Batman Returns is my favorite live-action Batman movie. For one, Batman Returns is a quintessential Tim Burton movie and that’s not a bad thing. Although I think Burton lost his touch over the years, his great films carried his trademark themes on sympathizing and empathizing with social outcasts. Batman Returns not only unapologetically embraces the fantastical, comic book, and gothic elements of the source material, but it also applies Burton’s unique aesthetic and commentary on the struggles of duality that Batman, Catwoman, and The Penguin endure. The Bat, the Cat, and The Penguin can be viewed as what psychoanalyst and psychiatrist Carl Jung called the Shadow Self, i.e. our repressed self that gets pushed into our unconscious because we think society will disapprove of it.

In my interpretation, Burton portrays the duality as a struggle, not as a romanticized truth that these characters fully embrace. In other words, there’s a tragedy to it, especially with The Penguin. Similar to the protagonists in Edward Scissorhands and Beetlejuice, Burton shows us a Batman, Catwoman, and Penguin who struggle to conform to societal expectations and norms. Bruce struggles with being the billionaire playboy that society expects of him (and I know, is it really that much of a struggle as a billionaire?); Selina struggles with sexist gender role expectations, especially in her white male-dominated workplace; and Penguin struggles with living in mainstream society that is simultaneously repulsed and fascinated by his physical appearance.

If we view these characters from a trauma-informed lens, we can appreciate how their traumas shaped them. Each of their struggles with trauma are different, especially due to socioeconomic differences, yet interconnected. What Burton seems to highlight is that these three characters are not just drawn to each other as “heroes and villains,” or because of the plot, but as people with traumatic backgrounds. When Bruce hears about Oswald/The Penguin’s parents on TV, he empathizes with him and expresses that he hopes Oswald finds his parents. Bruce’s trauma is drawn to Oswald’s trauma.

The social awkwardness of Bruce Wayne is so under-appreciated by most people I talk to about the Tim Burton films, yet it carries so much weight if you pay attention to it. It’s clear in these films that Bruce is psychologically traumatized. Even in the first film, Bruce is having dinner with Vicki Vale where they are seated so far apart at opposite sides of a long table that they have to shout to hear each other. It’s a funny scene, sure, but Burton seems to understand that humor is a common defense mechanism to trauma. Bruce does not know how to socialize with others, especially in romantic relationships (and it’s no wonder why he has difficulty maintaining a long-term relationship). And, how could he? After his parents were murdered and he grew up isolated from the rest of mainstream society. The trauma is also prominent when Batman calls Joker “psychotic” and Vicki says, “Some people say the same thing about you.” Vicki then says that Batman is not exactly “normal,” to which Batman says, “It’s not exactly a normal world is it.” I love this point because in our own society, we place too much focus on diagnosing the individual, but as psychiatrist Frantz Fanon emphasized in his work, the society itself is built with structures of oppression. In other words, who is diagnosing society?

In Batman Returns, the social awkwardness is apparent in Bruce’s conversations with Selina. He is drawn to Selina because he sees her as a mirror of himself (he says this later to her in the film). Yet, Burton also juxtaposes the duality of class differences when we see Bruce suiting up in his high-tech cave where there’s an abundance of Bat costumes whereas Selina is struggling to suit up in her car while driving (Batman has the absurd luxury of a car that drives by itself). The Penguin struggles with the duality of growing up in a sewer and then being abruptly thrusted into mainstream/human society where he is being exploited and used by Max Shreck. This is why I think Burton wants us to sympathize with The Penguin. Again, it’s a tragedy.

It’s worth noting that Keaton’s approach to Batman is different than Bale’s and Pattinson’s. The latter see Bruce Wayne as the mask that Batman wears (i.e. the narrative being that Bruce died that night when his parents were murdered). However, Keaton stated in a recent interview that his approach to the character was through Bruce Wayne. That is, Batman is the shadow of Bruce Wayne. Keaton brings a humanity to the character, understanding that one cannot fully grasp an understanding Batman without Bruce’s trauma.

Also, the scene at masquerade ball is one of my favorite scenes. How brilliant is it that the only characters not wearing masks at a costume party are Bruce and Selina? The song, “Face to Face,” by Siouxsie and the Banshees only elevates the scene even more. Speaking of music, the Danny Elfman score is phenomenal and, like all great scores, gives the film its identity. The addition of the chorus is what makes me prefer this score over his ’89 Batman score.

Lastly, I would argue that Batman Returns is the one Batman film where the primary antagonist is the rich, corporate elite, as represented by Christopher Walken’s Max Shreck. There’s an old video clip of comedian Reginald D. Hunter infamously calling Batman “a conservative’s wet dream.” He criticizes Batman for using his wealth and advanced technology against street-level crime instead of going against “the industrialists, the super capitalists, the Murdochs, the Trumps.” These are all valid points and I think if there is any Batman film that is an exception to this critique, it’s Batman Returns. Sure, Batman fights against The Red Triangle Gang and The Penguin, but Shreck is masterminding a larger plot for corporate domination that shows no regard for the well-being of the citizens of Gotham, especially the marginalized.

Shreck reminds me of Lex Luthor a great deal. He presents himself as a generous philanthropist (“Gotham’s own Santa Clause”) who cares about the people of Gotham, world peace, and “unconditional love.” However, he has ulterior motives to build a power plant that would give him control of Gotham’s power supply. We later learn through The Penguin that Shreck killed his business partner Fred Atkins. When Selina finds out what Shreck’s real plans are, Shreck sees her as a threat and attempts to kill her.

Much is made about how violent and vampiric The Penguin is in this film, but the real sinister villain is Shreck, who cruelly exploits The Penguin’s desire to be accepted on the surface (mainstream) society. By propping up The Penguin as Mayor, Shreck can then use him as a puppet and have his plans to construct his power plant approved. Just as The Penguin’s character serves as a harsh reminder of how society mistreats and otherizes people who are different than the majority, Shreck’s character represents how capitalism can create the appearance that it is being benevolent, but is ultimately dehumanizing and cares only about feeding the greedy.

Anyway, these are just some general thoughts and feelings I have about my love for Batman Returns. By no means is it a perfect film. Like anything, there is much to critique, especially with regard to Bruce’s privilege and power, the objectification of Catwoman, and ableist tropes with The Penguin. The film noticeably lacks people of color (a problem throughout Tim Burton’s filmography) and there’s one scene that involves a brown man trying to rape a white woman, reinforcing the racist trope of the “dark stranger in the alleyway.”

The argument could be made that The Dark Knight is more rewatchable and entertaining, at least for mainstream audiences, but Batman Returns is, despite its issues, deeper psychologically, more symbolic, and complex in character development. The beauty of Batman Returns is its depth and ability to absorb the audience in its world. It doesn’t need to spell themes out for us. Like a unique painting or work of art, it allows for and encourages various interpretations.

What The Rise of Skywalker Teaches Us About Family (Spoilers)

RiseOfSkywalkerPoster

Warning: Major SPOILERS ahead for The Rise of Skywalker.

In his acceptance speech for the Irving G. Thalberg Memorial Award in 1991, George Lucas stated, “I’ve always tried to be aware of what I say in my films because all of us who make motion pictures are teachers. Teachers with very loud voices.”

This quote stayed with me ever since I heard it. As an independent filmmaker, it inspired me to focus on the types of stories I want to tell. As a professional counselor, it was easy to connect the quote to Albert Bandura’s Social Learning Theory and George Gerbner and Larry Gross’ Cultivation Theory. It makes sense that Lucas feels this way about his work because he has always maintained that Star Wars is for kids. In making movies for children, he wanted to be careful about what he was teaching them.

Although George Lucas is sadly no longer involved creatively in the Disney Star Wars films, I appreciate that the films continue the tradition of exploring relevant themes. And I believe The Rise of Skywalker, unlike the saga itself, has a deeply compelling message about family. In family and group therapy sessions, I’m often talking about what defines a family. When I work with clients to create genograms, it is often an exercise of self-discovery. Particularly, individuals notice patterns in their family history that they had not seen or thought about before. Recognition of family trends, relationship dynamics, and how certain traits get passed down from one generation to another can help people develop a deeper understanding of how their early life experiences shaped them.

Furthermore, genograms can help motivate people to live the lives they want. One person may see destructive behaviors and cycles of abuse in their family that they want to end, while another might see how distant and disconnected they’ve become from the supportive family that raised them.

We are not doomed to repeat the wrongs of the past. We have a choice to be something else. To me, this is the message of The Rise of Skywalker. Kylo Ren/Ben Solo and Rey are descendants of Sith Lords, and both of them are fighting their destinies in different ways (I still wish a different actor played Kylo/Ben, but that’s another discussion for another time). Sheev Palpatine, also known as Darth Sidious, plays a critical role in the family history for both characters: Not only is he the man who seduced Ben’s grandfather to the Dark Side, but he is also Rey’s grandfather! I knew Rey being a Palpatine was a popular theory among many fans, but I’m honestly surprised that J.J. Abrams took this route. I had personally hoped for Rey to being a Kenobi, but as I watched the big reveal unfold in The Rise of Skywalker, I realized how much more moving this narrative is.

Lucas described Palpatine as representing the devil. Ian McDiarmid, the actor who portrays Palpatine, took it further and stated the character is worse than Satan. In this sense, Rey is literally the granddaughter of the devil, the purest form of evil. I loved the dynamic of a Sith-inspired Skywalker versus a Jedi-driven Palpatine. On one end, there’s Kylo, who is fighting against the pull towards the light, and on the other, there’s Rey, who is consistently being tempted by the darkness in her.

I’m going to take a quick detour here because it’s worth making some deep cuts. I promise it connects to my point about family! For the uninitiated, there has been a theory for a long time that Palpatine is technically Anakin’s father based on a couple of sources: (1) George Lucas’ original draft for Revenge of the Sith and (2) a recent Darth Vader comic book published by Marvel. In the book, “The Making of Star Wars: Revenge of the Sith,” an original draft of Lucas’ script shows Palpatine/Darth Sidious revealing to Anakin that he “arranged” for his conception. Sidious says, “I used the power of the Force to will the midichlorians to start the cell divisions that created you.” The Marvel comic book seems to confirm the claim that since Palpatine learned from his Sith master, Darth Plagueis, how to manipulate midichlorians to create life, he used this power to impregnate Shmi Skywalker to create Anakin. The problem with this theory is that it’s heavily disputed. Lucas’ original draft for Revenge of the Sith is just that: a first draft, not canon. Moreover, the Marvel comic book does not definitively state that Palpatine is Anakin’s father; in fact, the illustrations indicate that Shmi Skywalker was already pregnant prior to Palpatine intervening. One fascinating theory argues that The Force itself created Anakin in retaliation to Palpatine’s efforts to manipulate midichlorians. In any case, I admit it’s super fun to consider the possibility that Palpatine is Kylo Ren’s great-grandfather in addition to being Rey’s grandfather!

Whether Palpatine is related to both Ben and Rey, or just to Rey, my point is, people are not destined to become their parents if they don’t want to. Anyone who works in family therapy knows that breaking toxic and destructive patterns is not an easy task. We inherit things from our past, and while we are not guilty of committing the wrongs that may exist, we must take responsibility for what we choose to do with what we’ve inherited. This is not just relevant from a family systems perspective, but also through a social justice lens. Rey clearly has Force powers that she inherited from Palpatine and I’m not just talking about the Force lightning. Her ability to manipulate midichlorians to create life (ok, fine: “heal”) comes from Palpatine, who learned it from Darth Plagueis (by the way, I love how important the prequels are to this movie!). What she chooses to do with her power is what contributes to determining her destiny, and I think she realizes this when she thought she inadvertently killed Chewbacca (and thank God she didn’t because it was “Vector Prime” all over again for me!). In an article about privilege, the author Jamie Utt quotes a mentor: “If we inherit injustice, we should never feel guilty. We are not responsible for that past. However, if we choose to do nothing about it going forward, then we have plenty to feel guilty about.”

The Rise of Skywalker is being criticized for not taking risks, but I would argue that the film’s ending is an interesting subversion of the saga’s view of bloodlines. When Luke declared to Palpatine in Return of the Jedi that he is a Jedi “like my father before me,” he proudly embraces his heritage as a Skywalker. After all, in a spiritual sense, it is Anakin Skywalker who is Luke’s father, not Darth Vader. Rey, on the other hand, is not a Skywalker by blood, but rather adopts the name. She rejects her “birthright” to the throne her grandfather offered. I’m surprised that I’ve heard some fans complain that Rey cannot be a Skywalker because she is not blood-related to Luke or Leia. But what The Rise of Skywalker does so beautifully is that it challenges conventional definitions of family. Family is not always about who you’re related to by blood, but rather about people you choose; people who accept and embrace you as who you are. And who you are is who you choose to be.

As Leia says to Rey, “Never be afraid of who you are.”

The Problems with Aladdin: Orientalism, Casting, and Ramadan

Edward Said and Jack G. Shaheen did not do the work they did so that movies like Aladdin would still get made.

I say this as someone who has had a complicated relationship with the 1992 Aladdin animated feature. I loved it when I was a kid. For a long time, it was my favorite Disney cartoon. I remember proudly telling white friends and classmates in third grade that Aladdin was “about my people.” Although nothing is said in the movie about Aladdin’s religion, I read him as Muslim.

When I grew older, I read Jack G. Shaheen’s book, Reel Bad Arabs, which analyzes about 1,000 American films that vilify and stereotype Arabs and Muslims. Among these films is Aladdin, which Shaheen reportedly walked out of. Shaheen spoke out against lyrics in the film’s opening song: “I come from a land from a far-away place/Where they cut off your ear if they don’t like your face/It’s barbaric, but hey, it’s home.” Although he convinced Disney to remove the lyrics for the home video release, the final verse was still there: “It’s barbaric, but hey, it’s home.” As a 1993 op-ed in The New York Timeswrote, “It’s Racist, But Hey, It’s Disney.”

In Edward Said’s seminal book, Orientalism (1978), he described orientalism as a process in which the West constructs Eastern societies as exotic, backwards, and inferior. According to Said, orientalism’s otherization of Arabs, Muslims, and Islam provided justification for European colonialism and Western intervention in the Middle East and Muslim-majority countries, often under the pretext of rescuing the people — especially Muslim women — from themselves. In addition to orientalism’s practices of constructing the “Orient” as the West’s “Other,” Said asserted that another major facet of orientalism involves a “western style for dominating, restructuring, and having authority over the ‘Orient.’” In other words, it is not the Arab or Muslim who gets to define themselves, but rather the West does.

There are plenty of excellent and detailed critiques out there about how the original Aladdin is filled with racist, sexist, and orientalist tropes, so there’s very little, if anything, to say that already hasn’t been said. In her extensive report, “Haqq and Hollywood: Illuminating 100 Years of Muslim Tropes And How to Transform Them,” Dr. Maytha Alhassen argues that Hollywood’s legacy of depicting Arabs and Muslims as offensive caricatures is continued in Aladdin, where the main characters like Aladdin and Jasmine are “whitewashed, with anglicized versions of Arabic names and Western European (though brown-skinned) facial features” and speak with white American accents. Alhassen notes the contrast with the “villains, Jafar, and the palace guards” who are depicted as “darker, swarthy, with undereye circles, hooked noses, black beards, and pronounced Arabic and British accents.” In another article, “The Problem with ‘Aladdin,’” Aditi Natasha Kini asserts that Aladdin is “a misogynist, xenophobic white fantasy,” in which Jasmine is sexualized and subjected to tropes of “white feminism as written by white dudes.” Not only does Jasmine have limited agency in the film, Kini writes, but her role in the film is “entirely dependent on the men around her.”

When Disney announced plans to produce a live-action remake of Aladdin, I learned through conversations that the Aladdin story is not even in the original text for Alf Layla wa Layla, or One Thousand and One Nights. It was later added by an 18th century French translator, Antoine Galland, who heard the story from a Syrian Maronite storyteller, Hanna Diyab. Galland did not even give credit to Diyab in his translation. Beyond the counter-argument that “the original Aladdin took place in China,” I am left wondering, how much of the original tale do we really know? How much did Galland change? It’s possible that Galland changed the story so significantly that everything we know about Aladdin is mostly a western, orientalist fabrication. For a more detailed account about the origins of the Aladdin tale, I recommend reading Arafat A. Razzaque’s article, “Who ‘wrote’ Aladdin? The Forgotten Syrian Storyteller.”

Disney has been boasting about how the live-action Aladdin is one of the “most diverse” movies in Hollywood, but this is an attempt to hide the fact that the casting of this film relied on racist logic: “All brown people are the same.” It’s great that an Egyptian-Canadian actor, Mena Massoud, was cast in the lead role, but there’s inconsistency elsewhere: Jasmine is played by British actress Naomi Scott, who is half Indian and half white; Jafar is played by Dutch-Tunisian actor Marwan Kenzari; and Jasmine’s father and a new character, Dalia, are played by Iranian-American actors Navid Negahban and Nasim Pedrad, respectively. The casting demonstrates that the filmmakers don’t know the differences between Arabs, Iranians, and South Asians. We are all conflated as “one and the same,” as usual.

Then there’s the casting of Will Smith as the genie. Whether deliberate or not, reinforced here is the Magical Negro trope. According to blogger Modern Hermeneut, this term was popularized by Spike Lee in 2011 and refers to “a spiritually attuned black character who is eager to help fulfill the destiny of a white protagonist.” Moreover, the author writes that Lee saw the Magical Negro as “a cleaned up version of the ‘happy slave’ stereotype, with black actors cast as simpleminded angels and saints.” Examples of the Magical Negro can be found in films like What Dreams May Come, City of Angels, Kazaam (which also features a Black genie), The Green Mile, The Adjustment Bureau, and The Legend of Bagger Vance. In the case of Aladdin, the genie’s purpose is to serve the protagonist’s dreams and ambitions. While Aladdin is Arab, not white, the racial dynamic is still problematic as the Magical Negro trope can be perpetuated by non-Black people of color as well.

I need to pause for a moment to explain that I don’t believe an Aladdin movie should only consist of Arab actors. Yes, Agrabah is a fictional Arab country, but it would be perfectly fine to have non-Arabs like Iranians, South Asians, and Africans in the movie as well. That’s not the issue I have with the casting, and this is not about identity politics. My problem is that the filmmakers saw Middle Eastern and South Asian people as interchangeable rather than setting out to explore complex racial, ethnic, and power dynamics that would arise from having ethnically diverse characters existing within an Arab-majority society. Evelyn Alsultany, an Associate Professor who was consulted for the film, states in her post that one of the ways Disney tried to justify casting a non-Arab actress for Jasmine was by mentioning that her mother was born “in another land.” However, this seems to have been Disney doing damage control after they received some backlash about Jasmine’s casting. The result is convenient erasure of an Arab woman character. Moreover, the change in Jasmine’s ethnicity does little, if anything, to reduce the film’s problematic amalgamation of Middle Eastern and South Asian cultures. Alsultany writes that “audiences today will be as hard pressed as those in 1992 — or 1922, for that matter — to identify any distinct Middle Eastern cultures beyond that of an overgeneralized ‘East,’” where “belly dancing and Bollywood dancing, turbans and keffiyehs, Iranian and Arab accents all appear in the film interchangeably.”

Other examples of how the film conflates various Middle Eastern and South Asian cultures is highlighted in Roxana Hadadi’s review: “Terms like ‘Sultan’ and ‘Vizier’ can be traced to the Ottoman Empire, but the movie also uses the term ‘Shah,’ which is Iranian monarchy.” Referring to the dance scenes and clothing, she writes they are “mostly influenced by Indian designs and Bollywood styles” while “the military armor looks like leftovers from Ridley Scott’s Kingdom of Heaven.” An intersectional approach to the diverse ethnic communities represented in the film would have made for a more nuanced narrative, but this would have required a better director.

Speaking of the director, it is amazing that, of all people, Disney hired Guy Ritchie. Because if there is any director out there who understands the importance of representation and knows how to author a nuanced narrative about Middle Eastern characters living in a fictitious Arab country, it’s… Guy Ritchie? Despite all of the issues regarding the origin of the Aladdin story, I still believed the narrative could have been reclaimed in a really empowering way, but that could not happen with someone like Guy Ritchie. It’s textbook orientalism to have a white man control the narrative. I would have preferred socially and politically conscious Middle Eastern and Muslim writers/directors to make this narrative their own. Instead, we are left with an orientalist fantasy that looks like an exoticized fusion of how a white man perceives South Asia and the Middle East.

Lastly, I have to comment on how this movie was released during the Islamic holy month of Ramadan. In fact, the film’s release date, May 24th, was just one day before the last ten days of Ramadan, which are considered to be the most important in the month. During Ramadan, Muslims around the world fast — if they are able to — from dawn to sunset every day for 30 days. The time when we break our fast, iftar, typically involves dinner and prayer with family, friends, and/or the community. But Ramadan is more than just about fasting, it’s a time of self-reflection, compassion, and strengthening our connection with Allah, our loved ones, and community. I don’t believe Disney released Aladdin during Ramadan intentionally. If anything, I think the film’s release date is reflective of how clueless and ignorant Disney is. It’s so ridiculous that it’s laughable.

I don’t want to give the impression that Muslims don’t go out to the movies during Ramadan. Of course there are Muslims who do. I just know a lot who don’t— some for religious reasons and some, like myself, for no other reason than simply not having enough time between iftar and the pre-dawn meal, sehri (I mean, I could go during the day, but who wants to watch a movie hungry, right?). Even Islamophobic Bollywood knows to release blockbuster movies on Eid, not towards the end of Ramadan.

But this isn’t about judging Muslim religiosity during the holy month. No one is “less” of a Muslim if they are going to the movie theater or anywhere else on Ramadan. My point is that Disney has not shown any consideration for the Muslim community with this movie. They did not even consider how releasing the film during Ramadan would isolate some of the Muslim audience. It’s clear that Disney did not make efforts to engage the Muslim community. Of course, there is nothing surprising about this. But you cannot brag about diversity when you’re not even engaging a group of people that represents the majority of the population you claim to be celebrating! In response to Shaheen’s critiques of the original Aladdin cartoon, a Disney distribution president at the time said Aladdin is “not just for Arabs, but for everybody.” But this is a typical dismissive tactic used to gloss over the real issues. No doubt Disney will follow the same script when people criticize the latest film.

I don’t have any interest in this movie because it failed to learn anything from the criticism it received back in 1992. The fact that a 1993 op-ed piece titled, “It’s Racist, But Hey, It’s Disney” is still relevant to the live-action version of a film that came out 27 years ago is both upsetting and sad at the same time. As I said earlier, Edward Said and Jack Shaheen did not exhaustively speak out against orientalism, exoticism, and vilification to only see them reproduced over and over again. Of course Disney refused to educate themselves and listen to people like Shaheen— their Aladdin story was never meant for us.

Supergirl, Superman, and Kryptonian Identity

supergirlsuperman

Warning: Spoilers below for Supergirl seasons 1-4, including the Elseworlds crossover episodes!

If you had asked me who my favorite superhero was three years ago, I would have answered without hesitation, “Superman.” When people complained that the man of steel is “too overpowered,” I would encourage them to look beyond his superpowers if they truly wanted to appreciate him. Integral to his story is an immigrant narrative about belonging and identity. To me, Superman had potential to be radically reimagined as a character who stood against oppression and injustice, no matter who perpetrated it. It seemed possible to imagine an iteration of the character where he wasn’t a symbol of U.S. nationalism, but rather an outsider who stood up for all of humankind, most especially the marginalized and downtrodden.

Many commentators have pointed out that Superman can serve as an allegory for undocumented immigrants (watch Hari Kondabolu’s brilliant video about that here). An episode on Smallville addressed this directly when Clark helps an undocumented Mexican immigrant teen. At one point, Clark declares to his Earth-mom, Martha, that he himself is an “illegal alien.” The moment in the show was certainly a subversive one. Not only did it challenge Clark/Superman’s typical “boy scout” image, it also gave us a glimpse of who Superman could be if he was detached from his patriotic allegiance to the U.S. nation-state. Often times, Superman is described as representing “the best in all of us,” but what complicates this characterization is the contradictory forces of being a “good person” and aligning one’s self with a country that perpetuates oppression. Black Panther touched upon this struggle when T’Chaka tells his son T’Challa, “You are a good man, with a good heart. And it’s hard for a good man to be a king.”

As compelling as the aforementioned episode of Smallville was, what remained disappointing about the film and TV depictions of Superman is that any exploration of an immigrant allegory relied on liberal ideas of patriotism and national identity. In other words, the underlying theme with Superman seemed to be more about assimilation than anything. One can draw parallels between Superman’s relationship with his Kryptonian heritage and racial/ethnic identity among people of color in the U.S. As entertainment blogger/journalist Monique Jones writes:

Superman exhibits a wrestle with the Model Minority stereotype… [H]e is an immigrant who can go unnoticed, in a sense, in white society. Because he has the ability to do that, it’s assumed that Superman will always play by the rules and uphold the ladder of racial privilege.

Furthermore, she argues that Superman’s “journey is very much one of a person who slowly becomes much more empowered by their ancestral history.” I’ve been longing to see a depiction of Superman that reflects this statement for a long time, and while there are moments where we’ve seen him be more embracing of his Kryptonian heritage, I’ve felt that it’s always his Americanness that emerges as the dominant identity. Zack Snyder took this even further in 2013’s Man of Steel where Superman willfully refuses to save anything remaining of his homeworld of Krypton. In the scene (that I continue to dread), Zod pleads with Superman to not destroy the ship because it carries the ability to recreate Krypton. Superman’s eyes light up red and he bellows, almost demonically, “Krypton had its chance!” With his teeth gritting, he screams and shoots laser beams into the ship.

If we understand assimilation as a violent process that is detrimental to one’s psychological well-being, as French-Algerian revolutionary scholar and psychiatrist Frantz Fanon argued, then we can acknowledge the larger implications for Superman’s violent response to Zod. As psychologist Chi-Ah Chun and sociologist Jung Min Choi attest, assimilation not only involves people of color internalizing “norms that undermine their identities and histories,” but it also leads to them “fleeing from themselves.” In the powerful documentary, Color of Fear, a Black male participant, Victor Lewis, describes the violence of assimilation into U.S. society:

There is no American ethnicity. You have to throw away your ethnicity to become American. That’s what it means. You give up who you are to become American. And you can pretend that it’s ok because you’re white. When we give up who we are to become American, we know that we’re dying from it.

When applying this framework of assimilation to Superman, a character who is from another planet and adopts Earth as his new home, his destruction of Zod’s ship in Man of Steel symbolizes violent severance of one’s roots. In order to become an Earthling (which is basically code for “American” in the larger narrative), he must destroy the Kryptonian within. Historically, we have seen how assimilation played an integral role in cultural genocide against Indigenous Peoples, specifically through the U.S. boarding school system where it was instructed to “kill the Indian in him, and save the man.”

It wasn’t until I watched the Supergirl TV show when I realized that her character is much closer thematically and politically to how I wished Superman was. While it definitely doesn’t take a radical leftist approach to her character, there are aspects of the show that I believe are worth engaging with.

For starters, the show makes an important distinction about the immigrant parable. In the most recent season, Supergirl is reframed as a refugee, not an immigrant. The difference between the terms is significant and it makes sense when we consider that both Supergirl and her cousin, Superman, didn’t choose to leave Krypton, but rather fled as their world was being destroyed.

Supergirl’s real Kryptonian name is Kara Zor-El, and while she adopts the surname “Danvers” from her Earth parents, she doesn’t change her first name. Superman on the other hand didn’t know his Kryptonian name until he was older, so he went by his Earth name, Clark Kent. In the early seasons of Smallville, after Clark finds out that his birth name is actually Kal-El, he is fiercely against people addressing him as such.

Unlike Superman, Kara grew up on Krypton and was 13 years old when escaping the dying planet. Although Kara was taken in by the Danvers family on Earth, she still holds on to her Kryptonian heritage. Whereas Clark initially runs away from his Kryptonian roots, Kara embraces them. In her adulthood, we see that she practices the Kryptonian faith (Raoism), speaks the Kryptonian language fluently, and has fond memories of living on Krypton. Kara still struggles with reconciling her Kryptonian and Earth identities, but it takes on a different form than Clark’s.

During season 3, Kara discovers that her home city, Argo City, had survived Krypton’s destruction and was floating on an asteroid thanks to technology developed by her father, Zor-El. She also learns that her mother, Alura Zor-El, is alive and well. Kara decides to move back to Argo City because it is, after all, home to her. Of course, her stay on Argo City didn’t last long as she needed to return to save Earth. This was predictable, but it was nice to see Kara reconnect with Kryptonian friends and family.

The episodes on Argo City reminded me of an arc on Lois & Clark where Kryptonian survivors tell Clark that he needs to leave Earth and join them on New Krypton to stop a civil war. By the end of the arc, Lois asks Clark, “Did any part of meeting up with your roots feel good? Was it satisfying in any way or was it disappointing to you?” Clark replied, “Maybe all of those. I kept waiting for this incredible feeling of connection and like I was exactly where I belong, but that’s only happened once in my life.”

The one moment of connection that Clark refers to is the time he met Lois. As romantic as the scene is, it was also a disappointing one for me. Again, if we’re looking at Superman as an undocumented immigrant struggling to fit in, the lesson here seems to be, it doesn’t matter where you came from because your Americanness erases all of that. But the narrative was already set up that way since there was nothing likable or sympathetic about the way Kryptonians were portrayed. In contrast, what was unique in Supergirl was that it was the first time we saw a Kryptonian protagonist valuing and appreciating their culture. If the lesson in Lois & Clark is to forget your roots, one could make the argument that Supergirl promotes embracing one’s identity and history.

What’s interesting with Supergirl is that it introduced Clark/Superman in the second season. Consistent with the show’s appreciation for Kryptonian culture, Clark asks Kara at one point if she would share stories with him about Krypton. This is quite different from the Clark we’ve seen in other versions. Moreover, during the Elseworlds crossover event, Clark reveals that Lois is pregnant and that both of them have decided to move to Argo City for a while. In addition to it being safer for Lois’ pregnancy, the move to Argo City also gives Clark the opportunity to reconnect with his lost heritage. Some fans are critical of Clark making this decision because it may seem like he’s “abandoning” the people of Earth, but as he says in the episode, he trusts his cousin Kara to protect the planet.

But like all TV shows and movies, Supergirl is not without its issues. Back during season 2, I wrote a critique on Facebook of the show’s social and political commentary on immigrants and refugees. It was similar to X-Men except it focused on the human persecution of aliens instead of mutants. An anti-alien organization known as Project Cadmus created an “Alien Registry” that reminded me of Trump’s calls for a “Muslim registry” (the show has been addressing issues that are very consistent with current events, so I don’t believe for a second that these references are coincidental). Cadmus’ plan was to deport all aliens off Earth. Sound familiar?

While I appreciated the show’s positive intentions, what frustrated me about season 2 is that it utilized a “Good Alien/Bad Alien” binary. Just like the “Good Muslim” is the state-friendly citizen who doesn’t speak out against Islamophobia and imperialism, the “Good Alien” in Supergirl cooperates with the Department of Extra-Normal Operations (DEO), a secret government organization that deals with extra-terrestrial threats, reminiscent of Homeland Security. Whereas Democrats and Republicans fantasize Muslims to be the “eyes and ears” on the “front lines” in U.S. wars against Muslim-majority countries, the DEO view “Good Aliens” (particularly the Good Kryptonian, Supergirl) as their best defense against the “Bad Aliens.” When the DEO want to catch the “Bad Aliens,” they rely on the “Good Aliens” (and sometimes interrogate and torture them) to give them information (because all aliens know each other, right?). This carried unsettling implications for communities of color, suggesting that our value is only within the context of national security.

By season 4, I think Supergirl has made some significant improvements. Where the show deserves credit is that its allegory doesn’t fall into the trap of imagining a world that is post-racial and post-gender (unlike the X-Men films). In other words, the show acknowledges that racism, sexism, homophobia, transphobia, and xenophobia still exist. This season introduced the show’s first transgender woman superhero, Nia Nal. Last season, during the 19th episode, the show addressed police brutality against Black people. The show’s Black superhero, James Olsen (or Guardian), tries to stop the kidnapping of a young Black woman named Tanya, but when the police arrive, they point their guns at him while perceiving the white kidnappers to be the victims. Olsen is ordered to his knees and the white characters are asked if they’re ok.  Despite Tanya telling the police, “This is Guardian!” they refuse to listen to her — which seemed to be a case of misogynoir. Later in the episode, Olsen opens up to Lena Luthor about his experiences as a Black man, including the time when he was arrested by police at the age of 7.

There are still some missed opportunities on the show when it comes to race and gender. For example, at the beginning of season 4, J’onn Jonzz tells Kara that she doesn’t experience anti-alien prejudice because she “passes as human.” As true as this statement is, it’s not specific enough. What would have been more accurate is if Jonzz said, “You pass as a white human.” The show established before that Jonzz has experienced anti-Black racism despite being able to pass as human. What makes his experience different from Kara’s is that he embodies a Black man. This may sound like a trivial critique to some, but details like this matter to me.

Season 4 is undoubtedly about Trump and extremist right-wing groups. Instead of being white supremacists, the Children of Liberty are a group of anti-alien fascists who preach human supremacy and take up arms against extra-terrestrials. There is much to appreciate about this season, but there are also some issues with it, particularly the way the writers inaccurately imagine the radical left. That critique is better suited for another blog post!

In closing, what I appreciate about Supergirl is that it features an extra-terrestrial superhero who is not ashamed of her cultural roots. This is the Superman I wanted to see. It’s not a perfect narrative by any means – whereas Superman represented the problematic “melting pot” perspective on diversity, Supergirl represents problematic notions of “multiculturalism” (I recommend reading Sunera Thobani’s critique of multiculturalism for clarification on this point). As with most mainstream TV shows, I don’t expect anything radical, but I’d be lying if I said there weren’t things I appreciate about the show and its efforts to tackle important issues.

First Impressions of Zari Tomaz, Muslim American Superhero on DC’s Legends of Tomorrow

Zari

As you may have guessed, I’m very behind on the CW DC TV shows (aka the “Arrowverse”). I admittedly stopped watching Arrow after season 3 (more on that later), but continued to watch The Flash, Supergirl, and Legends of Tomorrow. As excited as I was to hear about a Muslim American superhero character being introduced on the show, the past year was quite busy for me (in a good way) and I got behind on my favorite shows!

I’m currently watching season 3 of Supergirl, season 4 of The Flash, and season 3 of Legends of Tomorrow. Last night, I finally got to the episode where we are introduced to Zari Tomaz, played by Tala Ashe, who is Iranian and Muslim American herself. I’m usually anxious with the way Muslim characters are portrayed in mainstream films and TV shows, but I was actually pleasantly surprised with how Zari is depicted. The Legends of Tomorrow team find her in the year 2042, where she is a hacker, rebel, and fugitive hunted by the A.R.G.U.S.-controlled government.

It’s a dystopian future where the government uses drones and martial law to enforce the Anti-Metahuman Act, where it is not only illegal to be a metahuman, but also illegal to practice Islam and other religions. I’m not a fan of the “all religions are banned” narrative because it’s hard to imagine a white supremacist future where Christian supremacy is non-existent, but it was nice to see an intersectional approach to a superhero character. That is, her racial and religious identities are taken into account in addition to her metahuman status. Her Muslimness is not erased by the latter. In other words, it makes sense that a Muslim woman of color with superpowers would be a threat to the state, right?

I like the fact there weren’t any negative stereotypes or tropes about her family (so far). We don’t see her family on screen, but she talks about her brother being murdered when police forces raided their home. Again, typically in western depictions of Muslim characters, we hear about them being oppressed by the Taliban (like X-Men’s Sooraya Qadir/Dust) or rejected by their own community. Rarely do I find stories that acknowledge Muslims as being targeted by institutionalized Islamophobia and western state violence. It was powerful to see that here.

The primary reason why I stopped watching Arrow is because of how Islamophobic it was getting, particularly with Ra’s Al Ghul and the League of Assassins. While Ra’s Al Ghul never explicitly identified as Muslim, he quoted the Qur’an frequently and recited Islamic prayers in Arabic (badly). I was uncomfortable with the way the show played up Orientalist and Islamophobic stereotypes. What makes Islamophobia in media so unsettling and harmful is that people project these stereotypes unto us. Throughout my life, for instance, I’d hear classmates, teachers, co-workers, and even friends draw conclusions about Muslims and my faith based on negative depictions they saw. After debating with people online about Islamophobia on Arrow, I remember saying at one point, why not have a Muslim superhero character on the show? Needless to say, a character like Zari was long overdue.

I appreciated how Zari’s introduction episode doesn’t over-emphasize the fact that she’s Muslim. Too often, depictions of Muslims focus exclusively on their religious identity and fail to portray them as complex, three dimensional human beings. I’ve felt for a long time that what we need to see are Muslim characters who are (1) played by Muslims and (2) treated like real people. The way Ashe and the writers approach Zari seems to be more well-developed and nuanced than how we’re used to seeing Muslims depicted.

There are also no tropes about overprotective parents who are trying to force her to marry someone. She’s not a character who requires saving by the other superhero characters. In fact, the moment we meet her, we take note that she is able to stand on her own. Although there’s an inaccurate use of the word “Jannah,” she seems to be unapologetic about being Muslim (again, so far). My hope is that the show continues to portray Islam as a source of strength for Zari, not a burden.

The only major problem I had with this episode is that she is also being targeted by a supervillain played by a Black woman. As much as I appreciated the way Zari is portrayed, I don’t think many filmmakers pay attention to racial dynamics in their casting of villains. Yes, there is Amaya, who is also a Black woman and ally to Zari, but I think having women of color fight each other is counter-productive and harmful. I’ve written about this before, but I’m generally not a fan of villains of color (superpowered or otherwise).

Anyway, I’m interested to continue watching the show, but more interested to hear how Muslim women are responding to Zari’s character. I look forward to finding posts written by Muslim woman about her character and will be linking to them here.